Examining (illicit) business practices of digital entrepreneurs in the ‘Uber-for-tractors’ network: Implications for Sustainability
Description
Studies into the morality of (digital) entrepreneurship are underexplored. Further, studies on Uber as an innovative business model and exemplar of disruptive entrepreneur that has re-organised the taxi industry are available as well as insights on ethics and entrepreneurship in the sharing economy- using Uber as a case. However, the novel application of this model in tractor service provision has received limited attention, especially with regard to combining digital and illicit entrepreneurship perspectives to enrich understanding around the question: what is the morality of entrepreneurial practices in the digital economy (the Uber-for-tractors network) and how do they influence platform sustainability. Therefore, we examine (illicit) practices of digital enterprises, focusing on a novel mobile application modeled on Uber to provide rural tractor services. Drawing on key informant interviews and farmer focus group discussions, the study analyses legal and illicit, and (un)productive, practices of digital entrepreneurs within the “Uber-for-tractors” net-work. The Technology Company (TC) behind the app sought to reduce farmers’ and tractor operators’ search costs, match them and earn commissions. However, adoption revealed widespread circumvention. The TC leverages social entrepreneurship to accrue donor subsidies, whilst accommodating matching using field agents. Operators booked clients offline to avoid declaring income to tractor owners, farmers inflated plot sizes or made multiple bookings, and tractors were “hijacked” through offline deals. These largely illicit and unproductive practices undermined the platform, with human intermediaries (field agents) emerging as central to transactions, while the app played only a supporting role. The findings highlight limitations of transplanting Uber-like models into agricultural contexts and caution against uncritical promotion of social entrepreneurship as a vehicle for sustainability. It reveals how such models maybe misappropriated and have potential to shift donor dependency from communities to enterprises in the guise of supporting business for development approaches.
Files
Steps to reproduce
METHODOLOGY Research approach The study followed a constructivist research philosophy and applied a phenomenological research design. Therefore, the study was qualitative in nature, to enable the researchers understand entrepreneurial opportunities and practices from the participants’ perspective. Sampling Purposive and snowball sampling methods were applied in the study. Purposive sampling was applied to engage with the target population consisting of all actors in the TC service network. These actors that were engaged with app being relevant and appropriate respondents to answer the study’s specific research questions. The TC representatives interviewed, specifically the manager and farmer agent (operative) itemised in the Table below were sampled based on direct involvement in the project area identified. Whilst tractor owners and operators were interviewed. Tractor owners and related operators were selected using snowball sampling. Table 1. Actors in TC service network sampled Actor Method Number TC – management representatives KII 2 TC – farmer agent KII 2 Tractor owners KII 12 Tractor operators KII 12 Farmer groups - 8 to 10 farmers FGDs 12 The sampling of farmers involved engaging the South Tongu District Agricultural Directorate. Once permission was sought through the Director, all the AEA’s managing the seven zones of South Tongu District mobilised farmers who were in the catchment of the TC for FGDs. Two groups were purposively selected in each zone – bringing the total number of FGDs targeted at 14. However, two FGDs failed to take place as farmers were unable to attend the scheduled meetings. Twelve FGDs were conducted across in South Tongu in Hikpo, Gordorkope, Fievie, Kpodzadzi, Dorkplame, Kpotame, Agbadzakope, Tsavanya, Dendo, Adutor, Atsieve, Dordeokope. Data collection Semi-structured interview guides and a FGD guide were used for data collection. Both instruments were pre-tested. The interview guide was administered to individual key informants and the FGD instrument was administered to farmer in groups. Prior to being involved in the study participants were required to sign informed consent forms. Data collection progressed from June 2023 to August 2023. Data analysis In terms of data analysis, transcribed data from the interviews and FGDs was manually subjected to thematic content analysis. The output of data analysis were code-document tables that highlight the range of themes that emerge from data in relation to the research questions. Specifically, by TC service network actors, the digital entrepreneurship opportunities regarding the app and the characteristics of these mechanisms (entrepreneurial practices). An initial coding scheme was developed based on insight from the literature review and the analytical framework.
Institutions
- Wageningen University and Research Research InstitutesGelderland, Wageningen
Categories
Funders
- Wageningen University Interdisciplinary Research and Education Fund (INREF)