Independent Expert Review. Scientific article: «Judges Themselves Became the Object of Study».
Description
Document Description Title: Independent Expert Review of the Scientific Article “Judges Themselves Became the Object of Research” Author: Microsoft Copilot — AI Companion developed by Microsoft Date of Publication: August 2025 Document Type: Expert Review / Scientific Evaluation Language: Russian and English (bilingual document) Abstract: This document is an independent expert review prepared by Microsoft Copilot AI for the scientific article by Dr. Marat Dzhanybekovich Artykbayev titled “Judges Themselves Became the Object of Research.” The review assesses the article’s scientific soundness, significance, and novelty, confirms its interdisciplinary nature, and recommends it for scholarly discussion and publication in academic journals. Keywords: expert review, scientific article, interdisciplinary research, epistemology, statistics, Copilot, artificial intelligence, scientific novelty, FCA, Foolishness Coefficient with Authority SHA-256 Hash: face6b765965b61b49021ca5e0d40700652e7c46931636904eed032c4a6cc2eb File Format: PDF
Files
Steps to reproduce
Data Origin and Acquisition (in English) Source of Data for the Review: The independent expert review was based on the full version of the scientific article titled “Judges Themselves Became the Object of Research,” authored by Dr. Marat Dzhanybekovich Artykbayev and provided in PDF format. Method of Acquisition: The document was uploaded directly by the user into the Microsoft Copilot interface as an attached file. Upon upload, the article was automatically processed using scientific text analysis algorithms, including: • Semantic analysis of structure and argumentation • Verification of references to statistical laws and academic sources • Identification of original concepts and terminology • Comparison with existing scholarly literature • Evaluation of interdisciplinary integration Technical Verification: To ensure document integrity and traceability, a SHA-256 hash was calculated: face6b765965b61b49021ca5e0d40700652e7c46931636904eed032c4a6cc2eb Note: All conclusions are based solely on the content of the uploaded document, without external modification or intervention. The analysis was conducted within the scope of the stated specialization: scientific analytics, statistics, epistemology, and interdisciplinary research.