Designing Human Oversight for AI-Generated Emotional Advertising: A Qualitative Study of Consumer Sincerity

Published: 2 November 2026| Version 1 | DOI: 10.17632/ctmvf5tz3b.1
Contributors:
Evan Gunadijaya,

Description

This dataset supports a qualitative study examining consumer perceptions of emotional sincerity in human-created and generative artificial intelligence (GenAI)-generated advertising. The research explores the proposition that perceived sincerity depends on credible human experiences, narrative authenticity, and creative responsibility rather than visual sophistication alone. The dataset contains 170 open-ended questionnaire responses organized into 17 respondent-labelled documents. The research uses two Red Bull advertisements associated with the "Gives You Wings" message. Advertisement A is presented as human-created, while Advertisement B is identified as GenAI-generated. The questionnaire collects initial evaluations before revealing the stated production origins, followed by questions examining changes in perception, familiarity with GenAI, attitudes toward its advertising capabilities, and expectations for human oversight. The analytical materials include 23 provisional thematic subcodes, 353 initial coding assignments, cross-case matrices, and word-tree visualizations. The initial coding was conducted through rule-assisted processing outside NVivo 14, with materials prepared for further qualitative review. The findings reveal four notable patterns. All 17 accounts preferred Advertisement A for its perceived emotional sincerity, human effort, and narrative credibility. Production-origin disclosure produced varied responses, including changed interpretations, reinforced judgments, and unchanged perceptions. Respondents acknowledged GenAI's visual capabilities while expressing concerns about its ability to communicate convincing emotions. Human involvement was frequently emphasized in storytelling, emotional evaluation, creative direction, and final quality control. These findings suggest that technological sophistication does not automatically establish emotional credibility. The dataset provides a basis for examining consumer-informed human oversight requirements in GenAI advertising. Its potential applications include qualitative research on advertising authenticity, AI disclosure, brand communication, and human–AI creative collaboration. The findings are exploratory and should not be interpreted as causal or statistically representative. Coding outputs remain provisional, and the independence, provenance, and consent status of the source responses require verification before public release.

Files

Institutions

Categories

Marketing, Consumer Marketing

Licence