Triadas

Published: 1 November 2026| Version 1 | DOI: 10.17632/s84zmw76ys.1
Contributors:
Anna Engel,

Description

Study on the sustainability of pedagogical transformations through students’, families’ and teachers’ perceptions of five personalized learning principles: experiential learning, culturally responsive learning, student decision-making, alignment with students’ interests, and connections across learning contexts. The unit of analysis is the student-family member-teacher triad. Hypotheses: (1) the principles are recognized at least moderately; (2) recognition does not imply convergence among informants; (3) schools with an explicit personalized learning project (PL) show greater recognition and convergence than non-PL schools; (4) recognition and convergence are positively related to perceived student engagement. Data: 465 complete triads from 14 purposively selected schools in the province of Barcelona (Spain), 2022-2023 school year. A three-version instrument (student, family, teacher; Catalan and Spanish) included three items per principle and one engagement item (participation in lessons for students and teachers; the child’s effort in their studies for families), rated from 1 (strongly disagree) to 4 (strongly agree). Approved by the Bioethics Commission of the University of Barcelona (IRB00003099). Data are anonymized. File: 2026-08-11_BBDD_Triadas.xlsx contains raw data only and the item wording of each version. Each row is one informant; triad members share an ID number preceded by A (student), F (family) or P (teacher). School variables: code (1-14), stage (1 primary, 2 secondary, 3 both), size (1 small, 2 large), sociocultural level (1 low, 2 medium, 3 high), type (0 non-PL, 1 PL), ownership (1 public, 2 publicly funded private). Findings: high recognition does not necessarily imply high convergence, and their combination varies substantially across schools. Recognition was positively associated with engagement for four of five principles; convergence was not. A PL project was associated with greater recognition and convergence only for student decision-making. H1-H2 supported; H3-H4 partially. Indicators (per triad and principle): Recognition = mean of the three informants’ responses to each item, averaged across the three items (1-4; higher = greater recognition). Convergence = range of the three responses (max - min) to each item, averaged across items (0-3; closer to 0 = greater convergence). Discrepancies are treated as substantive information, not error. Cut-offs: high recognition >= 3; high convergence <= 1 (scores rounded to two decimals). High recognition plus high convergence indicates shared cultural appropriation. Reuse notes: responses are ordinal (the study used Spearman and Mann-Whitney U, alpha = .05); engagement is a single item worded differently for families; triads are nested in schools of very unequal size (2-97 triads); some school variables are collinear and not all combinations are represented; data reflect perceptions; the purposive sample limits generalization.

Files

Categories

Education, Innovation

Licence