Structured Evidence Dataset for Graphene-Enabled Hybrid Solar Systems Review

Description

This dataset documents the structured evidence-control workflow underlying the critical review ‘From Graphene-Enabled Components to Integrated Hybrid Solar Systems: A Critical Review of Evidence, Integration Gaps, and Future Pathways.’ It contains (i) a claim-level article evidence matrix, (ii) a quantitative claim register identifying retained, qualified, and excluded numerical claims, and (iii) a citation crosswalk linking final manuscript reference numbers to permanent internal reference identifiers. The package is intended to improve transparency and traceability between scientific claims, evidence level, quantitative interpretation boundaries, and final citations. It contains derived review metadata only and does not redistribute copyrighted article full text or figures. Evidence levels are analytical boundaries used in the review and are not formal technology-readiness levels.

Steps to reproduce

1. Use GIHSP_Citation_Crosswalk_v1.0.csv to map submission citation numbers to permanent MRD identifiers. 2. Use GIHSP_Article_Evidence_Matrix_v1.0.csv to identify the source group, evidence boundary, limitations, and overclaim risk associated with each major manuscript claim. 3. Use GIHSP_Quantitative_Claim_Register_v1.0.csv as the controlling source for whether and how audited numerical values may be interpreted. 4. Consult DATA_DICTIONARY.md for field definitions and the L1–L5 evidence-boundary convention. 5. If a development-stage matrix entry conflicts with the final quantitative register, the final quantitative register governs the submitted manuscript.

Institutions

• Aerospace Research Institute

  Tehran, Tehran

Categories

Licence