Incineration or encapsulation? A robustness-tested fuzzy Delphi–fuzzy TOPSIS model for green pharmaceutical waste treatment in Malaysia
Description
This dataset contains the anonymised expert judgements behind a fuzzy Delphi–fuzzy TOPSIS model for selecting a green treatment for pharmaceutical waste (scheduled wastes SW403 and SW405) in Malaysia. Nine experts with theoretical or practical experience in pharmaceutical waste management took part, numbered E1–E9: three engineers from the Ministry of Health Malaysia one officer from the national scheduled-waste treatment operator four managers and executives from health-care waste concession companies one academic Data were collected through an online questionnaire between March and June 2021. All responses use a nine-point linguistic scale, recorded as numerical points 1–9. The file Data_S1_expert_ratings_anonymised.xlsx contains six sheets: README: study description and variable guide. Experts: organisation, position, years of experience, highest education and gender of each expert. Scale: the nine linguistic terms for importance and for performance, with the triangular fuzzy numbers used in the analysis (point p is coded as (p−1, p, p+1) on a 0–10 universe). Criteria_importance: each expert's importance rating of the four green criteria (economic, environmental, social, technical). Subcriteria_importance: each expert's importance rating of the 31 sub-criteria, grouped by criterion. Treatment_performance: each expert's rating of how relevant each of four treatments (incineration, chemical disinfection, encapsulation, secured landfill) is to each criterion. How to use the data: The criteria and sub-criteria ratings are the input to the fuzzy Delphi method, which assesses expert consensus and derives weights. The treatment ratings are the input to fuzzy TOPSIS, which ranks the treatments. Higher ratings always mean more important or more desirable. Converting the points to triangular fuzzy numbers with the Scale sheet reproduces all results in the associated article. Names, e-mail addresses and submission dates were removed to protect participant confidentiality. The criteria hierarchy was verified with policymakers in an earlier phase of the project (Md Radzi et al., 2023, Kurdish Studies, https://doi.org/10.58262/ks.v11i2.414). This research was supported by the Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia through the Fundamental Research Grant Scheme for Research Acculturation of Early Career Researchers [RACER/1/2019/STG06/UUM//3].
Files
Institutions
- Northern University of MalaysiaKedah, Jitra
Categories
Funders
- Ministry of Higher EducationPutrajaya, Putrajaya